“The goose that laid the golden egg is now under repair” – Terrence Alan, San Francisco Entertainment Commission
The standing room only panel at last night’s quarterly digital music industry event at SoMa’s Pyramind, was called “What’s Shaking Down SF Music Venues?” It included Tim Benetti (co-owner, Bottom of The Hill), Debra
Walker (District 6 Supervisor Candidate, artist), Terrence Alan
(Entertainment Commission, California Music & Culture Association),
Mark Rennie (Entertainment Attorney representing 20 venues including
Great American Music Hall & Slim’s) and moderator Michael Winger
(Recording Academy SF Chapter).
According to the panelists, the bars, venues and clubs in your neighborhood aren’t only in danger of shut downs – they are enduring violent police raids at the command of state-run California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC). This is no joke, San Francisco, because the comedy venues are closing too.
According to the speakers, patrons of the arts are undergoing abusive assaults at venues, being physically searched on the spot, with employees pushed around, up against a wall, in every neighborhood around the city. They even say that there are videos of the raids, but that you can’t see them because they’re considered evidence and therefore not public.
But heed the news presented by the panel: music venues, bar owners & licensed party-throwers are reportedly getting handcuffed, their offices turned upside down, their computers seized, hit with fines that are impossible to meet.
In order to understand the desperate call for help from the entertainment commission, it’s vital to understand the politics behind it.
When you serve alcohol at a party, venue or bar, an ABC license is required – but that license also puts you at risk for scrutiny, because that license also grants ABC the right to “protect the state of California” by enforcing the license they grant. ABC itself filters to local divisions, where they match up with the Police Department, facilitated by one man, who reports to the mayor. Sounds great, but it’s seemingly a mess.
Entertainment Attorney Mark Rennie (representing Great American Music Hall, Slim’s & 18 other SF venues) explained that the owners of GAMH are not concerned about making money as much as they are about “doing it right and putting on good shows,” evidenced by their free yearly blue grass festival in the park. Meanwhile, Rennie argued that11 accusation packages were filed against clubs (The Fillmore, Bimbo’s, Slim’s to name a few) simply because the venues had changed their cuisine from mexican to french fries over the course of the last 10 years since the licenses were written.
Rennie went on to explain he “ended up in a 9 hour hearing and we won, but rather than just admit we won, ABC just pulled back the accusation which means they can bring it back at anytime. There are a number of clubs now speaking to a very skilled litigator for a counterattack because this is crazy, it’s like death by legal fees…and they can take our laptops at any time. It’s pretty amazing what’s going on in our streets right now. You have these cowboy cops just riding roughshod on the constitution and I’m sick of it.”
“Part of the problem is a lack of focus on better planning, like not putting housing near venues,” points out Debra Walker, “the bottom line is that now people live near venues and they are calling police with complaints,” but even that doesn’t extend to all of the venues. Tim Benetti (co-owner, Bottom on The Hill) mentioned that Bottom of The Hill has always had great relationships with neighbors and few, if any, noise complaints.
Benetti said “Until now, neighbors have not affected us significantly. We know all of our neighbors, they love us. When we were told we had noise complaints we went door to door. we found out [ABC] was looking for problems, and [ABC] actually went door to door to neighbors asking for complaints and noise issues. We are friends with all our neighbors.”
The panelists argued that the failing California budget is also to blame, and alcohol violations yield big fines which clearly equals more money collected by the state. Said one, “It’s an issue of providing social services or arresting the problem. Now we’re also cutting arts from our budgets. I’m a firm believer that arresting a problem doesn’t solve it.”
At the same time, however, it’s nightlife that brings valuable revenue to the City. “The arts of San Francisco is what fills our hotel rooms,” points out
It’s too late for the closing or closed Annies Social Club, Poleng and Anna’s Jazz Island, and after an ABC raid two nights ago, Mojitos just might be an endangered species. What can you do to prevent the closure of your
favorite venue, bar or party – or, if you’re an artist, ensure that you’ll have a place to perform?
5 Suggestions From The Panel On How To Keep Music Venues, Bars & Entertainment Establishments Open
1. Write about it. We’re a city of bloggers under siege by the California Department of ABC. And, by the way, it’s happening all over the state! Get to work. At Flux Summit, the owner of Mojitos stood up and asked the crowd, “Why isn’t anyone writing about this? Where is the SF Weekly or the Chron? We are being strongarmed. When I go into work after this and the police show up like last night, what do I do?” He went on to describe their violent raid – just 2 nights ago. Bloggers, social media makers, internet artists, get on it.
2. Call The Mayor Day – Debra Walker suggested it, and everyone heard her. Call The Mayor Day is Tuesday February 9th. So, spread the word, sign up on Facebook or Plancast so you get a reminder and can share it with friends. For our first Call The Mayor Day, participants will call him to ask him to stop raiding our venues and destroying our livelihood and culture. Gavin can be reached at (415) 554-6141.
3. Go To More Shows – this one is obvious. Support your local music venues. They have ridiculous legal fees right now. Take your friends. Stop asking for guest list slots. You aren’t that important if you aren’t the artist on stage.
4. Join & Follow The California Music & Culture Association – this is a new association designed to preserve our state’s cultural lifeblood. Please support them by following CMAC on Facebook.
5. Shhhhhh & Hold Your Bladder – try not to be so noisy outside of the venues and bars and parties you love. Please don’t pee on peoples’ property, even if you can’t hold it. Lower your voice, just a little. Stop screaming like a crazy person on your way home. Just for now. You can yell when you call the mayor on February 9th.