Video, Slideshows: Liveblog Of Oscar Grant Trial Verdict, Response: News: SFAppeal

May 24, 2012 More Feeds

News

Video, Slideshows: Liveblog Of Oscar Grant Trial Verdict, Response

user-pic
  • 6 Comments
  • +1 Vote
  • Share
  • Email

2:49 PM: KTVU is reporting that a verdict's been reached in the Oscar Grant murder trial, and KCBS says it will be announced at...

These are the comments for Video, Slideshows: Liveblog Of Oscar Grant Trial Verdict, Response

(6)

user-pic

What an absurd observation from KRON: "There are no reports of riots." Feeding frenzy canceled, please go home. Like the old cross examination trick question: when did you stop beating your wife? What happens when cameras come out to film a riot that is not happening?

user-pic

I have no idea what this is supposed to mean.

user-pic

I think a more responsible framing of the story would be "Oakland remains quiet". I agree that "no reports of riots" sounds like a desperate media wanting a bleeding, leading story when their isn't one.

user-pic

The EBX is reporting that the Alameda County DA says Mehserle could get up to 14 years thanks to the "gun enhancement" on the involuntary manslaughter conviction.

http://www.eastbayexpress.com/92510/archives/2010/07/08/mehserle-faces-up-to-14-years-in-prison

But that depends on what sentence the judge hands down -- for all we know it could be time served plus probation.

user-pic

He'll walk after two.

user-pic

I feel like I need to explain...the trouble with KRON's comment is that it is pregnant with an expectation (that a "riot" would follw the verdict). Personally, I think reporting that there's no "riot" going on (thank you Sly Stone) is shoddy journalism. A "riot" is a violent anarchic act. A "demonstration" is a political act. In face, for most people in LA in 1992 (including myself), the word "riot" became a hot button issue, while many in the community preferred "uprising". Words matter, especially when the writer is implying that a riot could occur. Similarly, the old "when did you stop..." question implies a necessary predicate that has not been proven (i.e., that you ever beat anyone in the first place). There's no use in reporting that a riot has not occurred, unless that is exactly what you expect to happen.

Leave a comment

Have you read our comments policy? If not, please do.