OKCupid’s Volunteer Moderation System Raises Privacy Issues

Ever wonder how sites like ThatsNotOkCupid.com or NotSoNiceGuys.tumblr.com not only get away with posting various messages and pictures from a wide variety of OKCupid members? As the San Francisco Public Press reports, it may be because both sites are run by OKCupid moderators. Yes, moderators.

OKCupid’s moderators aren’t just unpaid, they’re OKCupid members chosen based on, reports the PP, an algorithm monitoring complaints and activity on the site.

Moderators are supposed to be checking profiles for material to delete, such as commercial solicitations and pornography. However, moderators are also privy to other information, including private messages that may contain personal information such as names and phone numbers. While many moderators simply read a flagged message and move on, the aforementioned sites take those messages and post them publicly with nothing more than names redacted.

Though it appears that OKCupid, whose parent company is Match.com, has tightened its moderation restrictions since the Public Press reached out to them in February, the issue of privacy and access has come into question across the board. Berkeley consumer protection attorney Jonathan Jaffe tells the Public Press that he sees the case as a legal minefield. Lawyers at Baker Botts LLP, who defended Match.com in a class action lawsuit, declined to comment.

Co-founder Sam Yagan tells the PP that the site has done nothing wrong stating that many other social networking sites utilize similar systems of moderation.

Though it is true that many forums and sites like Reddit employ the services of unpaid members, it seems that the very nature of OKCupid’s website calls issues of privacy into question. So, what do you think?


the author

Always in motion. April Siese writes about music, takes photos at shows, and even helps put them on behind the scenes as a stagehand. She's written everything from hard news to beauty features, as well as fiction and poetry. She most definitely likes pie.

Please make sure your comment adheres to our comment policy. If it doesn't, it may be deleted. Repeat violations may cause us to revoke your commenting privileges. No one wants that!
  • OKCMod

    I’ve been an OKC moderator for a good few months. I don’t check that tab very often, but when I do, there are usually only like 5 items up for review, and it’s usually just pictures that were stolen from elsewhere. I think I’ve personally seen one message interaction. None of this is stuff that would generate enough content for a blog. That is absolutely not the only – or main – way those sites get their entries.

  • OKCMod

    I’ve been an OKC moderator for a good few months. I don’t check that tab very often, but when I do, there are usually only like 5 items up for review, and it’s usually just pictures that were stolen from elsewhere. I think I’ve personally seen one message interaction. None of this is stuff that would generate enough content for a blog. That is absolutely not the only – or main – way those sites get their entries.

  • Joni Strickfaden

    Over 55 yrs old, I have reported daily at least 2 Scammers a day, that are ALWAYS removed within <36hours, in the past month… this could all be avoided if there was a small verification process fee?? Date on NEW profile or NEW profiles highlighted for 90 days to warn women of SCAMMERs… this site is the magnet for Nigerian scams Preying on older woman…. sometimes it is not only the MONEY, but our time that is wasted… and erodes trust in men!

    I would NEVER pay for this site

  • Joni Strickfaden

    Over 55 yrs old, I have reported daily at least 2 Scammers a day, that are ALWAYS removed within <36hours, in the past month… this could all be avoided if there was a small verification process fee?? Date on NEW profile or NEW profiles highlighted for 90 days to warn women of SCAMMERs… this site is the magnet for Nigerian scams Preying on older woman…. sometimes it is not only the MONEY, but our time that is wasted… and erodes trust in men!

    I would NEVER pay for this site

  • London Katie

    I recently was informed (unintentionally) that there are groups of “moderators” abusing their power on OkCupid.

    And since my personal information is apparently being spread across the Web (or it would be if I hadn’t taken precautions ahead of time), here is a screenshot of the “moderator” — username is KTLondon1 for the sake of anyone wise enough to Google her before a date — unintentionally broadcasting that she and other people are abusing their powers as moderators:

    http://imgur.com/a/JOlNr