plastic_bags.jpgSan Francisco supervisors today delayed a vote on a proposal to institute a fee for each checkout bag a store in the city provides out of concern about a lack of outreach to the small businesses that would be affected.

The legislation, introduced by Supervisor Ross Mirkarimi, would also expand a law passed by the board in 2007 banning supermarkets and chain store pharmacies from providing single-use, non-compostable plastic bags, extending it to all retail establishments in October 2012, then restaurants in 2013.

The 10-cent fee for each paper bag used would be kept by the businesses to use how they see fit.

Mirkarimi had amended the legislation, which initially proposed an eventual 25-cent fee and went into effect three months earlier, and said the city’s Department of the Environment had done outreach to small businesses throughout the city.

But several supervisors said they had recently talked to small business owners who were unaware of the proposal.

“I know some outreach has happened, but I just don’t think enough has happened,” Supervisor Jane Kim said, adding that minority communities in neighborhoods like Chinatown were especially shocked to hear about the legislation.

Kim and other supervisors said they planned on supporting the proposal once more outreach is done.

Mirkarimi said the same arguments were made to try to delay the initial bag ban when he proposed it years ago, as well as a Styrofoam ban the city instituted.

A vote on expanding the ban was already delayed once by the board two weeks ago.
He said “the sky did not fall” when those laws went into effect, and said he worried that the delay was “a Trojan horse for dilution” of the proposal.

Nevertheless, the board voted 7-4 to again delay a vote on the legislation until its Feb. 7 meeting.

Mirkarimi said before today’s meeting that the legislation would decrease what he said was an estimated 350 million plastic bags San Franciscans use annually and spur a shift by customers toward the use of reusable bags.

“It’s a very easy habit to learn,” he said.

Mirkarimi won’t be around to vote on the proposal though–he was
elected as San Francisco’s sheriff in November and will attend his last meeting as a supervisor next week before taking his new office in January.

Dan McMenamin, Bay City News

Want more news, sent to your inbox every day? Then how about subscribing to our email newsletter? Here’s why we think you should. Come on, give it a try.

Please make sure your comment adheres to our comment policy. If it doesn't, it may be deleted. Repeat violations may cause us to revoke your commenting privileges. No one wants that!
  • zrants

    Use a carrot instead of a stick.

    Banning both plastic and paper bags is a terrible idea. Get rid of plastic if you like, but leave us the paper bags for recycling trash. People will have to buy bags anyway if they don’t get them free at the store. And since plastic is cheaper and lighter, they will buy plastic bags. A better solution is for stores to offer a discount to people who bring their own. Some stores do that now.

  • zrants

    Use a carrot instead of a stick.

    Banning both plastic and paper bags is a terrible idea. Get rid of plastic if you like, but leave us the paper bags for recycling trash. People will have to buy bags anyway if they don’t get them free at the store. And since plastic is cheaper and lighter, they will buy plastic bags. A better solution is for stores to offer a discount to people who bring their own. Some stores do that now.