sfpd_cityhall.jpgConcerned by the Chronicle’s explosive report on how, they say, about 80 SFPD officers “have criminal histories or misconduct records that the Police Department withheld and prosecutors did not disclose to defense attorneys in cases in which officers testified”?

You’re not the only one: Public Defender Jeff Adachi has, understandably, called a press conference for 11 AM today to, in the words of his release, “comment on San Francisco District Attorney Kamala Harris’ failure to disclose criminal convictions and evidence of misconduct of more than 80 police officers.” Calling out the aspiring Attorney General by name? ZING.

The Chronicle says that the fallout from this revelation could be even more severe that that from the SFPD drug lab scandal. Adachi agrees, saying that this issue “will make the problems at the crime lab look like small potatoes.”

Here’s the deal: legally, it’s a prosecutors’ responsibility to let defense attorneys know when a witness at a trial (like a drug lab employee or a cop) has been arrested, convicted, or even accused of some types of crimes. This is so, like you’ve seen on TV a zillion times, defenders can go after a witnesses’ character in an overall move to discredit their testimony.

In San Francisco, the police department’s been expected to volunteer this information to the DA’s office, but if the Chron report is accurate, the SFPD wasn’t volunteering, and the DA’s office wasn’t asking.

This Don’t Tell, Don’t Ask policy could result in the overturn of hundreds of felony convictions, but we’re sure Adachi will have more details on how he wants all that to go down at 11 today.

the author

Eve Batey is the editor and publisher of the San Francisco Appeal. She used to be the San Francisco Chronicle's Deputy Managing Editor for Online, and started at the Chronicle as their blogging and interactive editor. Before that, she was a co-founding writer and the lead editor of SFist. She's been in the city since 1997, presently living in the Outer Sunset with her husband, cat, and dog. You can reach Eve at eve@sfappeal.com.

Please make sure your comment adheres to our comment policy. If it doesn't, it may be deleted. Repeat violations may cause us to revoke your commenting privileges. No one wants that!
  • bloomsm

    Travesty of justice for the accused. Whatever “side” you are on (cops vs. perps), a fair trial is a constitutional right. And that right must be guaranteed by the DA, not by the police department. The DA controls what goes on in the courtroom, not the cops.

    Say goodbye to statewide office, Ms. Harris. Your stance on the death penalty, Debra Madden, and this? Hasta.

  • bloomsm

    Travesty of justice for the accused. Whatever “side” you are on (cops vs. perps), a fair trial is a constitutional right. And that right must be guaranteed by the DA, not by the police department. The DA controls what goes on in the courtroom, not the cops.

    Say goodbye to statewide office, Ms. Harris. Your stance on the death penalty, Debra Madden, and this? Hasta.

  • SeanD

    Would that it were true, Bloomie – all the latest info suggests Kamala’s poll numbers have been rising these past few months, hell, she even got the Guardian’s endorsement! They completely glossed over her negligence and dinged her opponent for using employees to do personal business. We get what we deserve…

  • SeanD

    Would that it were true, Bloomie – all the latest info suggests Kamala’s poll numbers have been rising these past few months, hell, she even got the Guardian’s endorsement! They completely glossed over her negligence and dinged her opponent for using employees to do personal business. We get what we deserve…

  • bloomsm

    So true SeanD, we do get the government we deserve.

  • bloomsm

    So true SeanD, we do get the government we deserve.

  • Matt Stewart

    Another self-righteous crusade by the ever-indignant Jeff Adachi? I guess that means he thought the press wasn’t giving him enough attention.

  • Matt Stewart

    Another self-righteous crusade by the ever-indignant Jeff Adachi? I guess that means he thought the press wasn’t giving him enough attention.